Critique 2 Research Proposal Papers

One Page Critique for each Papers (2 in total) - Need the following evaluations:- - Summary (*). Summarize the paper for the authors, so that they can realize whether the submission is clear. - Soundness (*). Claimed contributions of a paper should be supported through the rigorous identification of appropriate research methods. The claims should be scoped to what can be supported, and limitations should be discussed. Also include your rate, excellent, good, poor, very poor. - Significance (*). Contributions will be evaluated for their novelty, originality, and importance with respect to the existing body of knowledge. Submissions will be expected to explicitly argue for the relevance and usefulness of the research and discuss the novelty of the claimed contributions through a comparison with pertinent related work. Also include your rate, excellent, good, poor, very poor. - Presentation Quality. Submissions are expected to meet high standards of presentation, including adequate use of the English language, absence of major ambiguity, clearly readable figures and tables, and respect of the formatting instructions provided below. Also include your rate, excellent, good, poor, very poor. - Overall evaluation (*). Please provide a detailed review, including a justification for your scores. Both the score and the review text are required. Also include your rate, excellent, good, poor, very poor. Due: Sunday, 17/12/2017 at 10pm CET.